Retrievist / Reviews / Dog Toys / No-Stuffing Dog Toys / 12 No-Stuffing Dog Toys For Messy Chewers
12 No-Stuffing Dog Toys For Messy Chewers
Does your dog remove the stuffing from toys as soon as they get their paws on them? It’s a total pain, we know. Not only does it create a fluffy mess around the house, but it also gets expensive to replace all these plus toys. Plus, stuffing from toys is at risk to be ingested if left on the ground, and your dog could be at risk of a blockage after swallowing it.
Thankfully, stuffing-free dog toys keep these problems at bay and are good for pets that are especially rough on their playthings. Here are the most popular ones, according to dog owners and reviews.
Best Overall No-Stuffing Dog Toy
- squeakers
- long-lasting
- fun
- double seams
- durable construction
- long-lasting squeakers
Built with double seams and double lining, this no stuffing toy can withstand rough play with dogs of all sizes. The crinkle design eliminates the mess of stuffing being pulled out and the snake has multiple squeaker compartments to keep dogs interested and engaged in play.
With more than 26,200 Amazon reviews, this toy has an average 4.1-sta...
With more than 26,200 Amazon reviews, this toy has an average 4.1-star rating. Reviewers praise the size of the toy and the durability—not just of the toy but also of the squeakers.
- double seams
- durable construction
- long-lasting squeakers
- squeakers
- long-lasting
- fun
Built with double seams and double lining, this no stuffing toy can withstand rough play with dogs of all sizes. The cri...
With more than 26,200 Amazon reviews, this toy has an average 4.1-star rating. Reviewers praise the size of the toy and the durability—not just of the toy but also of the squeakers.
Best Budget No-Stuffing Dog Toy
- loud squeakers
- fun shape
- hard to tear
- throws far
- long-lasting
- unique squeaker shape
This doughnut-shaped toy has two crescent-shaped squeakers that fill the entire cavity of the toy. The squeakers fit tightly within the plush shell of the toy, making it harder for dogs to rip the toy while playing. This keeps dogs entertained, though some shoppers warn that tough dogs can get through the seams.
Reviewers particularly like ho...
Reviewers particularly like how easy the toy is to throw and for dogs to catch, as well as the fact that it bounces once thrown.
- throws far
- long-lasting
- unique squeaker shape
- loud squeakers
- fun shape
- hard to tear
This doughnut-shaped toy has two crescent-shaped squeakers that fill the entire cavity of the toy. The squeakers fit tig...
Reviewers particularly like how easy the toy is to throw and for dogs to catch, as well as the fact that it bounces once thrown.
Most Durable No-Stuffing Dog Toy
- Textured
- floppy
- Durable
- Tough
- Unique
- cute
This toy may not have stuffing, but your dog might not be able to tell the difference because it's "stuffed" with knots. This allows for tons of chewing on the knotted arms and legs, allowing the fox toy to last longer than most. Plus, you'll find different textures and squeakers that will make pooches excited to play.
This toy is extremely po...
This toy is extremely popular with more than 2,000 Chewy reviews. Buyers mention that it lasted up to daily chewing, with the face being destroyed before the knotted bits did.
Knotted ropes and squeakers inside the toy provide interesting textures and sounds to keep dogs entertained.
What Humans Love:Minimal stuffing leads to less mess, and this rope-filled plush toy is adept at standing up to hours of play.
This toy may not have stuffing, but your dog might not be able to tell the difference because it's "stuffed" with knots....
This toy is extremely popular with more than 2,000 Chewy reviews. Buyers mention that it lasted up to daily chewing, with the face being destroyed before the knotted bits did.
Our Other Favorites
- squeaks
- crinkle feature can be added
- floppy design
- durable
- water bottle compartment
- frog shape
This stuffing-free frog plush toy holds up to tough players. It has a built-in squeaker to keep dogs engaged and a velcro compartment that holds an empty plastic water bottle for an added crinkle feature. Dogs love using it to shake, toss, and play.
With more than 1,800 Amazon reviews and a 4.2-star rating out of 5 stars, shoppers claim this t...
With more than 1,800 Amazon reviews and a 4.2-star rating out of 5 stars, shoppers claim this toy is long lasting—even up to aggressive chewers.
- durable
- water bottle compartment
- frog shape
- squeaks
- crinkle feature can be added
- floppy design
This stuffing-free frog plush toy holds up to tough players. It has a built-in squeaker to keep dogs engaged and a velcr...
With more than 1,800 Amazon reviews and a 4.2-star rating out of 5 stars, shoppers claim this toy is long lasting—even up to aggressive chewers.
- crinkle sounds
- squeakers
- floppy design
- two-pack
- machine washable
- multiple textures
This two-pack of octopus toys have no stuffing but rather squeakers in the heads of the toys and crinkle papers in the legs for plenty of fun. The lightweight design of the toys makes them great for fetch and tug for dogs and puppies of all ages. Plus, these toys are made with plush polyester exteriors and solid stitching and are machine washable for easy cl...
Reviewers say these cute octopuses became an instant favorite, giving them an average 4.5-star rating from more than 1,600 reviews on Amazon.
- two-pack
- machine washable
- multiple textures
- crinkle sounds
- squeakers
- floppy design
This two-pack of octopus toys have no stuffing but rather squeakers in the heads of the toys and crinkle papers in the l...
Reviewers say these cute octopuses became an instant favorite, giving them an average 4.5-star rating from more than 1,600 reviews on Amazon.
- multiple squeakers
- floppy
- crinkly
- multiple squeakers
- internal compartment
- durable
This floppy duck has squeakers in the head and in the tail to keep dogs engaged in play, and it's available in sizes small to large. Aside from being excellent for shaking, tugging, and fetching, there's an internal compartment that balls or empty water bottles can be put into.
With more than 15,0000 Amazon reviews, this toy has an average 4.3...
With more than 15,0000 Amazon reviews, this toy has an average 4.3-star rating and buyers love that its difficult for dogs to remove the water bottle.
- multiple squeakers
- internal compartment
- durable
- multiple squeakers
- floppy
- crinkly
This floppy duck has squeakers in the head and in the tail to keep dogs engaged in play, and it's available in sizes sma...
With more than 15,0000 Amazon reviews, this toy has an average 4.3-star rating and buyers love that its difficult for dogs to remove the water bottle.
- puncture-resistant squeakers
- fun shape
- good for rough play
- double-layered seams
- two-layer construction
- long-lasting squeakers
Designed for rough players, this gecko has two layers of fabric construction and double-layered seams as well as two squeakers that keep squeaking even if they are punctured during play. With more than 200 Chewy reviews, shoppers praise that their stuffing-removing dogs weren't able to do that with this toy and that the toy kept squeaking even with rough pla...
- double-layered seams
- two-layer construction
- long-lasting squeakers
- puncture-resistant squeakers
- fun shape
- good for rough play
Designed for rough players, this gecko has two layers of fabric construction and double-layered seams as well as two squ...
- squeakers
- floppy
- fun texture
- bright colors
- small dog friendly
- low price
This lightweight stuffing-free toy is ideal for small dogs and includes a squeaker for added fun. The floppy dog shape comes in multiple bright colors including blue, purple, green, yellow, and red. With more than Chewy 200 reviews, buyers note that the squeaker was exciting for their dogs and that the loofa fabric is a fun texture. But it is more suited for...
- bright colors
- small dog friendly
- low price
- squeakers
- floppy
- fun texture
This lightweight stuffing-free toy is ideal for small dogs and includes a squeaker for added fun. The floppy dog shape c...
- multiple squeakers
- multiple toys
- floppy design
- multi-pack
- cute designs
- medium size
These no-stuffing toys come in a three-pack and each one is shaped like a different woodland creature: a fox, a squirrel, and a raccoon. The large toys have two round squeakers and are for medium-sized dogs. With more than 2,300 reviews and a 4.2-star rating, people say their dogs go wild for the squeakers. Reviewers also noted that dogs who usually remove t...
- multi-pack
- cute designs
- medium size
- multiple squeakers
- multiple toys
- floppy design
These no-stuffing toys come in a three-pack and each one is shaped like a different woodland creature: a fox, a squirrel...
- multiple toys
- fun textured fabric
- squeakers included
- multiple toys
- fun designs
- non-toxic fabric
This multi-pack of stuffing-free toys is ocean-themed and comes with a crab, duck, octopus, devil fish, and crocodile. Each toy features a plush and/or corduroy exterior made of natural and nontoxic material that is soft but durable. The lightweight stuffing-free toys are easy for dogs of any size to play with and work well for those who enjoy carrying toys...
These toys have more than 1,200 Amazon reviews and an 4.2-star rating. Buyers appreciate that their dogs (including large-breed dogs) have been able to play with these toys for a long period of time, without any of the problems that arise with toys that include stuffing.
- multiple toys
- fun designs
- non-toxic fabric
- multiple toys
- fun textured fabric
- squeakers included
This multi-pack of stuffing-free toys is ocean-themed and comes with a crab, duck, octopus, devil fish, and crocodile. E...
These toys have more than 1,200 Amazon reviews and an 4.2-star rating. Buyers appreciate that their dogs (including large-breed dogs) have been able to play with these toys for a long period of time, without any of the problems that arise with toys that include stuffing.
- squeakers
- crinkle feature
- multiple toys
- multiple toys
- machine washable
- embroidered features
This pack of five toys includes a cow, fox, wolf, tiger, and squirrel that have crinkle features and squeakers to keep dogs engaged. They're made with thick fabric and stitching to help them hold up to a dog's boisterous play and are machine washable. The floppy toys are fun for dogs to carry and feature cute embroidered eyes and noses that can't be chewed o...
With more than 4,200 Amazon reviews, these toys have 4.5-star rating. Reviewers note that they hold up to multiple dogs and can be swapped interchangeably out to keep dogs engaged.
- multiple toys
- machine washable
- embroidered features
- squeakers
- crinkle feature
- multiple toys
This pack of five toys includes a cow, fox, wolf, tiger, and squirrel that have crinkle features and squeakers to keep d...
With more than 4,200 Amazon reviews, these toys have 4.5-star rating. Reviewers note that they hold up to multiple dogs and can be swapped interchangeably out to keep dogs engaged.
- realistic animal design
- stretchy
- squeakers
- durable construction
- internal rope
- stretchy
This stuffing-free toy resembles a realistic animal pelt that dogs can't get enough of. Rather than stuffing, the squirrel has a knotted rope as the filling that create stretchy movement to keep dogs engaged. This also makes it feel more like a plush toy and there's squeakers for some added fun. With more than 500 Chewy reviews, shoppers say their dogs took ...
- durable construction
- internal rope
- stretchy
- realistic animal design
- stretchy
- squeakers
This stuffing-free toy resembles a realistic animal pelt that dogs can't get enough of. Rather than stuffing, the squirr...
What to Know About No-Stuffing Dog Toys
Stuffing-free dog toys are plush toys that are designed to not have any filler stuffing in them. Sometimes they are flat toys that are just the plush "skins," and other times they are filled with large, hard-to-puncture squeakers, rope, or can be stuffed with a water bottle for added crinkle. s Because these toys don't have filling, they can be more durable and less messy than traditional stuffed dog toys.
In general, yes. There are no guarantees and it will depend on your dog and how they play with toys. In many cases, stuffing-free toys will last longer than other plush toys because the dog isn't enticed to rip out stuffing. You can also find toys with more durable stitching that can hold up to chewing.
These toys are still not safe for dogs to ingest. Dogs who are prone to eating toys should be closely monitored with all kinds, including-stuffing free toys. Always remove toys if your dog shows any interest swallowing them.
Stuffing-free toys can be part of an intentional training plan to teach dogs to play more gently. To do this, try intentionally engaging with your dog in play with their toys instead of allowing them to just sit and chew on them. Help your dog play appropriately by encouraging them to chase, fetch, and tug with toys instead of chewing.
