It’s worth taking some time to consider which toy your dog will like best, but don’t let it overwhelm you. The majority of dog toys aren’t hugely expensive, so if your dog doesn’t love the one you choose, you won’t have wasted too much money (plus some manufacturers accept returns). Ideally, your dog should have a range of toys to satisfy different needs, such as treat-dispensing toys or puzzle toys for mental stimulation, and fetch toys for physical stimulation.

What to Look for in a Dog Toy

Some dogs are naturally more playful than others, but almost all dogs will enjoy playing with certain toys if you choose the right ones. Before buying, however, you should learn more about dog toys and what types of toys appeal to what sorts of dogs.

We have that information here to help you buy a safe and suitable toy for your canine companion.

Types of Dog Toys

The huge range of dog toys available is sometimes baffling, especially for first-time dog owners. Listed below are some of the most common types of dog toys, with additional information to help you make the right choice.

Plush Toys

Plush dog toys are usually stuffed, but you can find low- or no-stuffing options. Most also feature one or more squeakers. Many dogs like these toys because they simulate prey. However, they’re best for dogs with soft mouths who enjoy carrying toys around and gently mouthing them, but aren’t destructive with their toys. While reinforced, durable plush toys do exist, they won’t stand up to determined chewers. Always supervise a dog who likes to chew these toys because ingesting them can be dangerous.

Chew Toys

The vast majority of dogs can appreciate a chew toy, since dogs have a natural urge to chew. That said, some dogs, especially puppies, are more keen on chewing than others, and chew toys can redirect problem chewing. Common chew toy materials include rubber and nylon (such as Nylabone chews), but specially engineered, wood chew toys are becoming more popular.

Fetch Toys

Fetch toys encompass any toys designed to be thrown by a human and returned by a dog, mainly balls and flying discs. Active dogs generally love fetch toys and will play fetch with you until your arm gets too tired to go on. Be careful to use toys that are not so hard that they’ll damage your dog’s teeth.

Interactive Toys

Interactive toys are toys that your dog can interact with in a meaningful way. This includes, but isn’t limited to, puzzle toys and treat-dispensing toys. Interactive dog toys are perfect for intelligent dogs, particularly those who get bored and act out if they aren’t provided with ample mental stimulation. These toys also offer a fun way to provide treats during training sessions.

Tug Toys

If you want to play with your dog, a tug toy is a great option. Usually, you hold one end, your dog holds the other, and you tug it out until one of you wins, but two dogs can also play with a tug toy without a human. Tug is a game that you should initiate and manage, so it doesn’t lead to improper behavior. Make sure your dog will “drop” if told, and if he gets overstimulated end the game.

Size of Toys

It’s important to choose the correct size toy for your dog. If you choose a size that’s too large, it will be hard for your dog to carry and play with. Even worse is choosing a toy that’s too small, since it could pose a choking hazard. Some dog toy manufacturers list a recommended weight range for each size of toy, which is handy. If in doubt, choose a toy with a return policy, so you can send it back if it isn’t right.

Durability

Select a dog toy that’s durable enough for your dog, especially when dealing with strong, determined chewers. A toy may be the right size for your dog, but still not durable enough. Although no toy is truly indestructible, for a heavy chewer you should choose toys labeled “indestructible,” “tough,” or “durable.”

Safety

Choose dog toys that are the correct size and level of durability for your dog, and you’re already well on the way to having a safe dog toy. It’s also a good idea to buy a toy from a trusted brand that you know is free from toxic materials. Very cheap dog toys may be poorly made or contain materials that could be harmful to your dog, as can some of the most common toys such as tennis balls. To keep your dog safe, it’s always best to supervise play sessions.