Retrievist / Reviews / Treats / Best Bully Sticks – Review of All-Natural Bully Sticks for Dogs
Best Bully Sticks – Review of All-Natural Bully Sticks for Dogs
Bully sticks are long-lasting dog chews made from 100% bull penis. This might sound somewhat revolting to us humans, but dogs love them. Plus, they don’t splinter like some chews, nor do they pose the same risk of choking and intestinal blockages as rawhide does since bully sticks are highly digestible.
We did extensive research to find the best bully sticks, looking at customer options and overall quality. This is what we found.
Overall Best Bully Sticks
- Moderate odor
- Long-lasting
- No additives
- Made from free-range beef
If you want to be sure about the provenance of any bully sticks you buy, these are a top choice. They're made in FDA-approved facilities in Texas and Nebraska from grass-raised beef farmed in North and South America (only in areas known for quality cattle-raising).
You can choose between 4 and 6 inch lengths in a range of thicknesses, so you'r...
You can choose between 4 and 6 inch lengths in a range of thicknesses, so you're sure to find an option that suits your dog. The impressive 4.4 rating comes from over 1,000 reviews.
These bully sticks come in different lengths and thicknesses for dogs of any size, and can keep even your pup busy for a while.
What Humans Love:Made from grass-fed beef in USA FDA facilities, there’s no questioning the quality of these additive-free bully sticks.
If you want to be sure about the provenance of any bully sticks you buy, these are a top choice. They're made in FDA-app...
You can choose between 4 and 6 inch lengths in a range of thicknesses, so you're sure to find an option that suits your dog. The impressive 4.4 rating comes from over 1,000 reviews.
Best Budget Bully Sticks
- Tasty
- Fun to chew
- Low odor
- No additives
- Range of sizes
No genuine bully sticks are especially cheap because they're made from 100% beef, but these ones have some affordable options, particularly the regular thickness in the shorter 6 inch length. You can, however, choose from a range of thicknesses and a longer 12 inch option.
Pack sizes range from 5 to 50 and while you obviously need to spend out...
Pack sizes range from 5 to 50 and while you obviously need to spend out more for a larger pack, it does work out cheaper per bully stick. That said, it's not by a huge amount per stick so use your discretion. These bully sticks have received hundreds of reviews with a 4.2 rating.
There’s nothing fancy about these bully sticks, but they get the job done and taste great to your dog. What more could they ask for?
What Humans Love:This budget-friendly brand of bully sticks is low-odor and is available in bags of up to 50, making them great for multi-dog homes.
No genuine bully sticks are especially cheap because they're made from 100% beef, but these ones have some affordable op...
Pack sizes range from 5 to 50 and while you obviously need to spend out more for a larger pack, it does work out cheaper per bully stick. That said, it's not by a huge amount per stick so use your discretion. These bully sticks have received hundreds of reviews with a 4.2 rating.
Most Durable Bully Sticks
- Fun chewing challenge
- Tasty
- Many hours of chewing
- Rugged
- Low odor
Bully sticks are fairly durable as they are, but these giant 12 inch bully sticks made from three bully pieces braided together definitely get our vote for the most durable bully sticks. Even the largest dogs with the strongest jaws will take a while to get through these.
Like all true bully sticks, they're made from 100% beef with no additive...
Like all true bully sticks, they're made from 100% beef with no additives. You can choose a range of pack sizes containing between 5 and 250 bully sticks. They're received an Amazon rating of 4.4.
Delicious and challenging, these bully sticks challenge both the taste buds and the mind.
What Humans Love:Long-lasting and odor-free, these bully sticks are safe and can keep dogs busy for hours.
Bully sticks are fairly durable as they are, but these giant 12 inch bully sticks made from three bully pieces braided t...
Like all true bully sticks, they're made from 100% beef with no additives. You can choose a range of pack sizes containing between 5 and 250 bully sticks. They're received an Amazon rating of 4.4.
Our Other Favorites
If you're looking for bully sticks for a puppy, small dog, or senior dog, these are relatively thin and therefore a suitable choice. Choose between two lengths: 5 to 6 inches or 11 to 12 inches.
Made from grass-fed, free-range beef, these sticks are processed to have a low odor, which is great for humans, though dogs especially love the stinky...
Made from grass-fed, free-range beef, these sticks are processed to have a low odor, which is great for humans, though dogs especially love the stinky ones. There are several package sizes to choose from, containing between 5 and 50 sticks. With over 1,000 reviews, these bully sticks have an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
If you're looking for bully sticks for a puppy, small dog, or senior dog, these are relatively thin and therefore a suit...
Made from grass-fed, free-range beef, these sticks are processed to have a low odor, which is great for humans, though dogs especially love the stinky ones. There are several package sizes to choose from, containing between 5 and 50 sticks. With over 1,000 reviews, these bully sticks have an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
- Great flavor and smell
- Durable
- Thick enough to last a while
Although these bully sticks are quite similar to the ones above, they have one major difference: they're thicker. As they're 30% to 50% thicker, these bully sticks are great for determined chewers who can get through a thinner bully stick in no time.
You can choose between 6 inch bully sticks, which come in a pack of 18, or 12 inch bully stick...
You can choose between 6 inch bully sticks, which come in a pack of 18, or 12 inch bully sticks, which come in a pack of 10. These sticks have a 4.4 rating from close to 1,000 reviews.
- Durable
- Thick enough to last a while
- Great flavor and smell
Although these bully sticks are quite similar to the ones above, they have one major difference: they're thicker. As the...
You can choose between 6 inch bully sticks, which come in a pack of 18, or 12 inch bully sticks, which come in a pack of 10. These sticks have a 4.4 rating from close to 1,000 reviews.
- Manageable size for smaller dogs
- Odor free
- Cattle raised without hormones
Made from premium grade grass-fed beef, these are quality bully sticks for dogs. They measure 6 inches long and are fairly slender, despite being marketed as thick, so are best for small and medium dogs. They have hundreds of reviews with a 4.3 rating.
They're odor free, which is great if you just can't stand the smell of bully sticks, but dog...
They're odor free, which is great if you just can't stand the smell of bully sticks, but dogs might not be as interested as they are in the stinkiest of bully stick. You can choose between a pack of 25 or a pack of 50.
- Odor free
- Cattle raised without hormones
- Manageable size for smaller dogs
Made from premium grade grass-fed beef, these are quality bully sticks for dogs. They measure 6 inches long and are fair...
They're odor free, which is great if you just can't stand the smell of bully sticks, but dogs might not be as interested as they are in the stinkiest of bully stick. You can choose between a pack of 25 or a pack of 50.
- Perfect thickness
- Good flavor
- Fresh
- No chemical treatments or additives
- Low odor
Although you can only buy these bully sticks in a 6-inch length, they're thick enough for big dogs (though not so thick that smaller dogs can't enjoy them, too). Thanks to a process of careful washing a slow baking, these sticks are odor free.
Made from grass-fed beef with no additives or hormones, you can be sure of the quality of these bully...
Made from grass-fed beef with no additives or hormones, you can be sure of the quality of these bully sticks, You can choose packs of either 15, 20, or 25, all of which have an average rating of 4.5 from around 900 reviews.
- Fresh
- No chemical treatments or additives
- Low odor
- Perfect thickness
- Good flavor
Although you can only buy these bully sticks in a 6-inch length, they're thick enough for big dogs (though not so thick ...
Made from grass-fed beef with no additives or hormones, you can be sure of the quality of these bully sticks, You can choose packs of either 15, 20, or 25, all of which have an average rating of 4.5 from around 900 reviews.
- Taste good
- Fun to chew
- Low odor
- No additives
- Long-lasting
You won't need to worry about the quality of these bully sticks. They're made in South America from local grass-fed beef with no additives or chemical treatments. Their 4.2 rating reflects their excellent quality overall, though some buyers expected them to be thicker.
Each bully stick is around 7 inches long with no other lengths available, b...
Each bully stick is around 7 inches long with no other lengths available, but you do have the option of various pack sizes, from 10 sticks to 250 sticks.
- Low odor
- No additives
- Long-lasting
- Taste good
- Fun to chew
You won't need to worry about the quality of these bully sticks. They're made in South America from local grass-fed beef...
Each bully stick is around 7 inches long with no other lengths available, but you do have the option of various pack sizes, from 10 sticks to 250 sticks.
- Great flavor
- Easy to digest
- Low odor
- Affordable
- Made from quality ingredients
With their moderate thickness, these bully sticks are best for medium chewers. Buyers can choose from two sizes: 6 inch chew that come 5 to a pack or 12 inch chews that come 3 to a pack.
They're made from free-range, grass-fed cattle with no additives, and have no discernible odor. With a 4.4 rating from a couple of hundred Amazon reviews, you...
They're made from free-range, grass-fed cattle with no additives, and have no discernible odor. With a 4.4 rating from a couple of hundred Amazon reviews, you can be sure you're getting a quality product.
- Low odor
- Affordable
- Made from quality ingredients
- Great flavor
- Easy to digest
With their moderate thickness, these bully sticks are best for medium chewers. Buyers can choose from two sizes: 6 inch ...
They're made from free-range, grass-fed cattle with no additives, and have no discernible odor. With a 4.4 rating from a couple of hundred Amazon reviews, you can be sure you're getting a quality product.
What is a Bully Stick?
A bully stick is a dog chew that can be given simply as a reward or treat, or to help clean teeth and satisfy your dog's natural urge to chew. Bully sticks are made from 100% beef. More specifically, beef penis or "pizzle."
This depends on the size of your dog and the size of the bully stick. Definitely not more than one per day, but possibly less. The calories from bully sticks (and other treats) shouldn't make up more than 10% of your dog's diet.
Compared to similar chews made from rawhide, bully sticks are very safe since they're easily digested and won't cause blockages. However, we'd still recommend at least loosely supervising dogs when they're chewing bully sticks.
Since they're made from 100% dehydrated bull penis, bully sticks have a distinctive natural odor. However, you can find low odor or odor free bully sticks that are washed and dried in a particular way to reduce the natural smell.
